County CommissionThursday, November 19
Sarasota County won't appeal the Live Local ruling on 864 apartments near the Celery Fields
The Daily Sarasota team
If you walk or bird-watch at the Celery Fields, here's where things stand. Sarasota County commissioners voted 3-2 Tuesday not to appeal Judge Hunter Carroll's Nov. 4 ruling, which requires the county to process D.R. Horton's application for 864 apartments on 51 acres next door.
Three commissioners voted to drop the Celery Fields appeal
Sarasota County Commission vote, Nov. 17
3–2
Drop the appeal and update the county's Live Local policy to follow the Nov. 4 ruling
Yes 3
- Knight
- Cutsinger
- DeNiro
No 2
- Mast
- Smith
Source: The Arizona Republic
View as table
| Member | Seat | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Tom Knight | Yes | |
| Ron Cutsinger | Yes | |
| Jim DeNiro | Yes | |
| Teresa Mast | No | |
| Mark Smith | No |
Commissioner Tom Knight, who made the motion, noted the legal cost of an appeal and the other Live Local suits could easily approach $4.5 million. “It’s not popular but it’s right,” he said. Chairman Ron Cutsinger was blunter: “We lost.”
Residents wanted a different outcome: nearly 60 people signed up to speak and more than 2,000 signed a petition. Next up are talks in the coming weeks with D.R. Horton, and commissioners still hope to buy the property to expand the Celery Fields' stormwater capacity.
- Settlement idea: 126 single-family homes, per D.R. Horton's attorney
- Apartment height as proposed: up to 65 feet
- Other Live Local suits: four pending before the same judge
The Celery Fields fight moved from court to the table
- JuneD.R. Horton takes the county to court over its rural land and Live Local.
- Nov. 4Judge Carroll rules for D.R. Horton and orders the county to process the application.
- Nov. 17Commissioners vote 3-2 to drop the appeal and update Live Local policy.
- Dec. 4Deadline to file a notice of appeal.