Latest issueSarasota Memorial and UnitedHealthcare reach a three-year dealRead now

← Sarasota news

County CommissionThursday, November 19

Sarasota County won't appeal the Live Local ruling on 864 apartments near the Celery Fields

The Daily Sarasota teamFrom Thursday’s edition · 1 min read · 4 sources

ShareEmailFacebookX

If you walk or bird-watch at the , here's where things stand. Sarasota County commissioners voted 3-2 Tuesday not to appeal Judge Hunter Carroll's Nov. 4 ruling, which requires the county to process D.R. Horton's application for 864 apartments on 51 acres next door.

Three commissioners voted to drop the Celery Fields appeal

Sarasota County Commission vote, Nov. 17

3–2

Passed

Drop the appeal and update the county's Live Local policy to follow the Nov. 4 ruling

Yes 3

  • Knight
  • Cutsinger
  • DeNiro

No 2

  • Mast
  • Smith

Source: The Arizona Republic

View as table
MemberSeatVote
Tom KnightYes
Ron CutsingerYes
Jim DeNiroYes
Teresa MastNo
Mark SmithNo

Commissioner Tom Knight, who made the motion, noted the legal cost of an appeal and the other Live Local suits could easily approach $4.5 million. “It’s not popular but it’s right,” he said. Chairman Ron Cutsinger was blunter: “We lost.”

Residents wanted a different outcome: nearly 60 people signed up to speak and more than 2,000 signed a petition. Next up are talks in the coming weeks with D.R. Horton, and commissioners still hope to buy the property to expand the Celery Fields' stormwater capacity.

  • Settlement idea: 126 single-family homes, per D.R. Horton's attorney
  • Apartment height as proposed: up to 65 feet
  • Other Live Local suits: four pending before the same judge

The Celery Fields fight moved from court to the table

  1. JuneD.R. Horton takes the county to court over its rural land and Live Local.
  2. Nov. 4Judge Carroll rules for D.R. Horton and orders the county to process the application.
  3. Nov. 17Commissioners vote 3-2 to drop the appeal and update Live Local policy.
  4. Dec. 4Deadline to file a notice of appeal.

Sources: The Arizona Republic, The Bradenton Times, ABC7 WWSB, Business Observer

Read it in the full edition

More from Thursday’s edition

Read the edition
All city hall news
  1. The Bradenton Times6 hours ago

    Manatee commissioners warn of ‘significant reductions’ following Amendment 3 passage, on The Bradenton Times

    At the first public meeting since voters approved a statewide tax cut, Manatee officials painted a stark picture of the county’s future, including staff reductions, selling properties, merging …

    Also reported byBradenton Herald

  2. Business Observer7 hours ago

    After $14.1M City Hall deal falls apart, Bradenton issues request for proposals, on Business Observer

    More than two years after the city of Bradenton entered into a purchase agreement with a developer to buy its City Hall property for $14.1 million, the deal has fallen apart. Vias at Bradenton LLC provided the city with a notice of termination of the agreement Sept. 30. City Council members were notified of the activity at their Nov. 18 meeting, where they voted unanimously to declare the property surplus; after taking that step, they could issue a request for proposals to redevelop it. The 4-acre waterfront site, at 101 12th Street W., houses City Hall and the Bradenton Police Department.…

  3. The Bradenton Times7 hours ago

    Manatee County Commission Notes: 12/17/26, on The Bradenton Times

    The League of Women Voters of Manatee County Government Committee observes Manatee County Commission meetings for items of interest to citizens and the League, and notes adherence to, or nonadherence …

  4. Bradenton Herald7 hours ago

    Manatee residents can save money on 2026 property tax bill. Here’s what to know, on Bradenton Herald

    Manatee County property owners have until Dec. 3 to secure a 4% discount on 2026 taxes, online, mail, and in-person payment rules and fees explained.