City HallFriday, November 6
Sarasota commissioners rejected the Obsidian tower for the third time
The Daily Sarasota team
If you've followed the Obsidian saga, city commissioners voted 3-2 Monday to reject the downtown condo tower for the third time. The decision sets the stage for a legal fight, and WGCU reports it is likely headed to circuit court.
The Obsidian would be tall for just 14 condos
- 320 feet
- tall, the tallest in downtown Sarasota
- 18
- stories, within the city's limit
- 14
- condo units in the proposed tower
- 3-2
- commission vote to reject it
Source: WGCU
A special magistrate had recommended approval, finding the city's earlier action unreasonable. Commissioner Kathy Kelley Ohlrich wasn't swayed. “This is a matter of compatibility — or the lack of it,” she said.
“My concern is that by rejecting this, we’re opening up the city to multiple millions of dollars in damages.”
Developer attorney Robert Lincoln said there will be legal action if the city again turned down the project. The Nov. 2 rejection of a mediated settlement sets up a potential Bert Harris suit against the city.
- Site: 1260 North Palm Avenue, beside the 14-story Bay Plaza
- Opponents: about 45 filled the chambers Monday
- Developer: Matt Kihnke, more than three years of effort
The Obsidian has been at City Hall since late 2022
- Late 2022Plans for the Obsidian first arrive at City Hall.
- May 2025Opponents pack commission chambers in red shirts.
- Nov. 2Commissioners reject the tower 3-2 for the third time.
Sources: WGCU, Sarasota Herald-Tribune
Sources: WGCU, Sarasota Herald-Tribune